Week 5: Modern Philosophy — Descartes and Locke
Week of Mon, Nov 2 · week closes Sun, Nov 8
This week's items
- Philosophical Forum 3 (choice)points in Canvas
- Discussion (counts toward your 2)points in Canvas
- Quiz (optional, not required)points in Canvas
Exact due times are in Canvas. P-TECH deadlines are on the course map at 11:59 PM, and the last one is Fri, Nov 20, four days before the course ends. Prof. Schumaker's rule: observe the due dates, expect reasonable penalties for late work, and ask him at least three days ahead if you need an extension. ACADEMIC INTEGRITY: use your own words and your own experience only. Plagiarism, or AI-written text turned in as yours, earns a zero, and a second violation is an F for the course (PGCC Code of Academic Integrity).
Read this week
- Meditations I and II — René Descartes — about twelve pages; read slowly, he is doing something on every page
- An Essay Concerning Human Understanding — John Locke (Book I ch. 1–2; Book II ch. 1, 8) — Book II chapter 1 is 'Of Ideas in General'; chapter 8 is primary and secondary qualities
Textbook chapters (Payne): Ch. 4: The Rationalists · Ch. 5: The Empiricists
Know these cold
- Descartes (1596–1650) wants knowledge as certain as mathematics. His method: doubt everything that can possibly be doubted and see what survives.
- Meditation I, three waves of doubt: the senses sometimes deceive; I might be dreaming right now; an evil demon might be deceiving me about everything, even arithmetic.
- Meditation II, the survivor: 'I think, therefore I am' (cogito ergo sum). Even if I am deceived, something must exist to be deceived. I am a thinking thing.
- The wax argument: a piece of wax changes every sensory property when heated, yet I know it is the same wax. So the mind, not the senses, grasps what things are.
- Rationalism: some knowledge comes from reason alone, independent of experience. Descartes is the model rationalist.
- Locke (1632–1704) answers: the mind at birth is a blank slate (tabula rasa). There are no innate ideas; every idea comes from experience — sensation (outer) and reflection (inner).
- Primary qualities (shape, size, motion, number) are in the object itself. Secondary qualities (color, taste, sound, smell) are powers in the object to produce sensations in us.
- Empiricism: all knowledge begins in experience. Locke is the model empiricist. Descartes vs. Locke is the modern version of Plato vs. Aristotle — reason vs. observation.
Discussion and forum — how to show up
Discussion post
- State in one sentence: does knowledge start with reason or with experience?
- Use one example of your own (not the wax, not the apple) and run it through both thinkers.
- Quote one line from either reading.
- Two replies that offer a counter-example.
Philosophical Forum 3 — can we be certain of anything?
- Position: yes / no / only of X — one sentence.
- Descartes' best argument for your side (or against it), with a Meditation reference.
- Locke's best argument, with a Book/chapter reference.
- Your strongest reason.
- Strongest objection and reply.
- What certainty, if any, you would want a doctor or a judge to have — and why.
Netiquette from the syllabus: address ideas, not people. Complete sentences, correct spelling. Personal matters go to email, never the board.
Major Essay 2 — outline
Confirm the exact prompt and rubric in Canvas. This outline fits a compare-and-judge essay on Descartes and Locke.
- Introduction: the question (where does knowledge come from?) and a thesis that picks a side on one specific point.
- Descartes in his own terms: method of doubt, the three waves, the cogito, the wax — with Meditation I/II references.
- Locke in his own terms: no innate ideas, sensation and reflection, primary and secondary qualities — with Book/chapter references.
- Head-to-head on one example you choose; show what each thinker would say and where they disagree.
- Objection to your thesis, stated fairly.
- Reply.
- Conclusion: what your answer means for how we should trust our senses or our reasoning today.
- Final pass: fallacy check, active voice, citations, rubric, file upload.
Write it in your own words. Cite the reading by author and section. Submit the file in Canvas before the deadline — P-TECH deadlines are on the course map at 11:59 PM, and the last one is Fri, Nov 20, four days before the course ends. Prof. Schumaker's rule: observe the due dates, expect reasonable penalties for late work, and ask him at least three days ahead if you need an extension. ACADEMIC INTEGRITY: use your own words and your own experience only. Plagiarism, or AI-written text turned in as yours, earns a zero, and a second violation is an F for the course (PGCC Code of Academic Integrity).
Meerk's quiz — open the Week 5 gate
10 questions, no time limit. One counted try: 85% opens the gate. Miss it and Meerk's Study Path opens: it teaches every miss back to you, then a mastery check — and it cannot finish before 25 minutes of real study. Then your second try opens. Work alone; the point is to know it, not to have seen it.
Stuck?
Raise your hand. Mr. James gets a message right away and can help you remotely. Nothing else is stored — just your last name, grade, and where you're stuck.
My Progress
Dinner Table Question
Ask at home: Descartes said the only thing he couldn't doubt was that he was thinking. What is one thing you are absolutely sure of — and how do you know?
En español: Descartes dijo que lo único que no podía dudar era que estaba pensando. ¿De qué estás absolutamente seguro, y cómo lo sabes?